The topic is short and compact
Since March 1, 2022, zinc pyrithione has been banned in cosmetics in the EU; older benchmark formulations containing it must be reformulated and re-evaluated.
According to the SCCS, climbazole has only been evaluated as an anti-dandruff active ingredient in rinse-off shampoos up to 2.0% and is out of the question as an active ingredient in a leave-on serum.
In a study of 65 adults, severely flaking areas were associated with higher levels of Malassezia restricta and Staphylococcus and lower levels of Cutibacterium, rather than higher levels of Malassezia overall.
Claims such as 'microbiome-friendly' or 'suitable for extensions' require substantiation on the finished product in accordance with Regulation (EU) No 655/2013.
Live probiotics and effective preservation are usually mutually exclusive in aqueous formulations; lysates, ferments, and prebiotics are particularly marketable.
So läuft die Entwicklung bei Labtree
1
Konzeptionierung
2
Bemusterung – Standardmuster in 24 h
3
Individualisierung
4
Prototyping
5
Produktion
White Label 2–3 Monate · Private Label 3–6 Monate · Produktion ab 1.000 Stück
Why is scalp care formulated like facial skin care?
The scalp is skin with its own barrier and its own microbial colonization, albeit under special conditions: dense hair coverage, active sebaceous glands, warmth under the hair, and regular exposure to surfactants, styling, and heat. Classic hair care has primarily treated this area correctively. An anti-dandruff shampoo is applied, left on briefly, and rinsed out.
Scalp care shifts the moment of application. Serums, tonics, and sprays remain on the skin after application; exfoliants are applied before washing and rinsed out after a defined contact time. This is part of skinification, in which facial care formats and active ingredients migrate into adjacent categories; the mechanics behind this are described in the article on the skinification of active ingredients.
For the formulation, this change has three consequences. A leave-on product has a longer contact time than a shampoo and enters the safety assessment with a different level of exposure. It must be compatible with the hair, meaning neither greasy nor sticky. And it does not compete with the shampoo, but complements it. A scalp care line is therefore not a shampoo with a new label, but skincare on a hairy surface.
What does research show about the scalp microbiome?
A scalp study using sequencing and qPCR data suggests that dandruff is associated with a shift in the proportions of less dominant microorganisms, rather than a simple excess of yeasts. Grimshaw et al. (2019) examined the scalps of 65 adults in Shanghai, 30 without and 35 with dandruff, at both the most and the least flaking sites.
Fungi: Malassezia accounted for more than 86% of the detected fungal taxa. The total proportion barely differed between the groups (94.5% versus 96.0%). At the most flaking sites, the absolute quantity (qPCR) of Malassezia restricta was higher, while that of Malassezia globosa was lower; the relative proportions of the species did not differ.
Bacteria: Cutibacterium and Staphylococcus dominated. At the most flaking sites, Staphylococcus was increased and Cutibacterium was reduced; Staphylococcus capitis increased with the severity of flaking, while Staphylococcus epidermidis decreased.
Limitations: This involves a single population, relative abundances, and correlations, not causal relationships. Sebum, pH value, and transepidermal water loss were not measured in the study; the authors mention an impaired barrier as a hypothesis.
For product development, this primarily implies an approach: a microbiome-friendly strategy does not mean treating the scalp with broad antimicrobials, but rather shifting the resident flora as little as possible and demonstrating this. To this end, a combination of in vitro testing—measuring the growth of relevant strains in the presence of raw materials or finished products—and a user trial with swabs taken before and after the application phase is recommended. Which strains and what timeframe make sense depends on the intended claim and should be determined before the study, not after.
Which anti-dandruff active ingredients are still permitted in the EU?
The most significant change in recent years concerns zinc pyrithione. With Regulation (EU) 2021/1902, zinc pyrithione was added to Annex II of the Cosmetics Regulation, i.e., to the list of prohibited substances, and deleted from Annex III as well as from the list of preservatives in Annex V. The ban has been in effect since March 1, 2022. Anyone wishing to recreate an older benchmark product or take over an existing item today therefore checks the INCI list first; a formulation containing zinc pyrithione must be completely reformulated and re-evaluated.
For climbazole, the Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety has established a narrow delineation by product type. According to SCCS opinion SCCS/1600/18, climbazole is safe as an anti-dandruff active ingredient up to 2.0% in rinse-off shampoos, as a preservative up to 0.5% in rinse-off shampoos, and up to 0.2% in leave-on products such as hair lotions, face creams, and foot care products, in each case under aggregated exposure. For an anti-dandruff leave-on serum, climbazole is therefore not a candidate active ingredient.
Other common active ingredients such as piroctone olamine or salicylic acid are likewise restricted by product type, with different limits for rinse-off and leave-on. The decisive factor is the currently applicable version of Annexes III and V of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009; it is checked before defining the formulation, not only during the safety assessment.
In addition, there is the distinction from medicinal products. According to Art. 2(1)(a) of the Regulation, a cosmetic product serves to clean, protect, keep in good condition, or change the appearance of skin and hair. Reducing visible dandruff generally remains within this scope; treating seborrheic dermatitis or a fungal infection does not. The wording on the packaging and product page co-determines the legal framework within which the product falls.
Probiotics, prebiotics, postbiotics: What can be formulated?
Live probiotics are the exception in aqueous cosmetic formulations, while lysates, ferments, and prebiotics are the rule. The review by Rezaei and Rollin (2026) summarizes the reason: preservatives at concentrations that inhibit or kill contaminants also inhibit or kill the desired strains. The authors cite water activity as one of the main reasons for the death of live cells in emulsions. Anhydrous or oil-based systems can support live cultures without preservation, but they involve compromises in skin feel and combinability; encapsulation is possible, but requires controlled capsule stability during manufacturing and filling.
For a scalp care line, this results in three realistic approaches:
Prebiotics: Substrates that certain skin bacteria preferentially utilize. They are non-critical from a formulation perspective, but they also serve as nutrients for contaminants and must therefore be evaluated as part of the preservative challenge test.
Postbiotics: Inactivated cells, lysates, and ferment filtrates. They can generally be combined with standard preservative systems. The raw material specification should list the strain, inactivation method, carrier substance, and any preservatives contained in the raw material, as these affect both the INCI list and the preservation concept of the finished product.
Live cultures: Conceivable only in anhydrous formats or with separated packaging or encapsulation. For a tonic or an aqueous serum, this approach is generally not economically feasible to manufacture.
This choice has direct implications for advertising claims. A product containing lysate contains no live bacteria; therefore, using the term “probiotic” without explanation easily conflicts with the criterion of truthfulness.
Why do leave-on formats like serums and tonics fail?
Most problems with a scalp formulation do not arise from the active ingredient, but at the interface between skin, hair, and packaging.
pH value: According to Dias et al. (2014), the pH value of the scalp is 5.5, while that of the hair shaft is 3.67; an alkaline pH increases the negative charge of the fiber and thus friction and frizz. A slightly acidic range is therefore recommended for leave-on products. Acidic active ingredients such as salicylic acid often require a lower pH value, which must be weighed against skin compatibility on sensitive scalps.
Alcohol and solubility: Ethanol dries quickly and leaves a light film, but can dry out sensitive scalps. Alcohol-free variants require other solubilizers for lipophilic active ingredients, which alters stickiness and viscosity.
Residue in hair: Oils, polymers, and film formers that are inconspicuous on facial skin weigh down hair at the roots. This is evaluated on strands of hair and in application tests after several hours of wear, not just immediately after application.
Applicator and packaging: Pipettes, spray pumps, and nozzle bottles each pose different requirements. A spray pump limits viscosity and requires a reproducible spray pattern, a nozzle bottle allows application along the parting, and a glass pipette requires testing for oxidation over the period of use. Formulations containing ethanol are additionally tested for gaskets, weight loss, and compatibility with the plastic of the packaging.
Extensions: Oils, high alcohol content, or surfactants near keratin bonds or tape-ins can affect adhesion. A claim such as “suitable for extensions” requires separate testing on typical attachment systems.
Scalp scrubs are usually pre-wash rinse-off products. Here, contact time, acid concentration, and rinsability are the decisive factors, and the instructions for use on the packaging are part of the safety assessment.
What testing does a scalp care line need before launch?
Legally, a scalp care line is an ordinary cosmetic product: safety assessment and safety report according to Art. 10 and Annex I of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, product information file, CPNP notification, and labeling. The differences lie in the tests, which carry more weight for leave-on products on a hairy, sebum-rich area.
Test | What it clarifies for the scalp care line |
|---|---|
Stability in the final packaging | Viscosity, pH value, odor, color, and precipitates at elevated and fluctuating temperatures, as well as weight loss in ethanol-containing formulations |
Preservative challenge test according to ISO 11930 | Whether the preservative system holds up despite prebiotics, sugars, or lysates acting as nutrients |
skin compatibility under dermatological supervision | Basis for claims regarding sensitive scalp, sensibly conducted with participants who classify themselves as sensitive |
Efficacy and microbiome | Dandruff assessment by trained personnel and swab analysis before and after the application phase, if dandruff or microbiome claims are planned |
Compatibility with hair and extensions | Residue, hair feel, and adhesion of attachment systems, if corresponding claims are planned |
Whether a claim is permissible depends on the common criteria of Regulation (EU) No 655/2013: legal compliance, truthfulness, evidential support, honesty, fairness, and informed decision-making. For the scalp, this primarily means: the effect of a raw material described in the data sheet is not yet proof for the finished product. How the test plan and time requirements are linked is described in the article on stability and safety testing, and the rules for claims in the article on cosmetic advertising claims in the EU.
A reliable entry point is a small line in which each product has its own moment of application: a leave-on serum or tonic for care between washes, a pre-wash scrub, and a mild shampoo that complements the line rather than carrying it. Shampoo and conditioner bring their own questions regarding surfactant systems and viscosity, which are covered in the article on private label hair care.
Labtree is a B2B cosmetic developer and cosmetic manufacturer with its own laboratory and production facilities in Germany, covering formulation development, in-house laboratory work, sampling, feasibility testing, and cosmetic production. Samples of pre-qualified formulations are usually dispatched from the sample warehouse within 24 hours, and standard sample shipping is free of charge; this allows the sensory profile, residue in the hair, and spray pattern to be assessed early on a physical product. In white label, a tested Labtree formulation is adapted and is generally ready for delivery within 2 to 3 months with standard packaging; a new private-label development typically takes 3 to 6 months to reach market readiness. The minimum order quantity is usually 1,500 units per product, depending on the product type, fill size, and packaging. The process is described on the cosmetic contract manufacturing page.
Which path is suitable depends on the planned claim. A care line without anti-dandruff or microbiome claims can manage with stability, challenge testing, and skin compatibility. A line with a microbiome claim additionally requires a study on the finished product, and its duration dictates the timeline more than the formulation development.
Quellen
More useful links
FAQ
Is an anti-dandruff product a cosmetic or a drug?
That depends on its intended purpose and presentation. A product that reduces visible dandruff and nourishes the scalp falls under cosmetics regulations. However, if you claim it treats seborrheic dermatitis or a fungal infection, you are heading into medicinal product territory.
What replaces zinc pyrithione in anti-dandruff formulations?
Climbazole in rinse-off shampoos, piroctone olamine, and salicylic acid are commonly used, each subject to limits per product type in Annexes III and V of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009. Replacing the active ingredient constitutes a reformulation requiring a new stability test and a new safety assessment, not merely a raw material substitution.
Can a product containing lysate be advertised as probiotic?
A lysate does not contain live bacteria. Under Regulation (EU) No 655/2013, claims must be truthful; therefore, it is advisable to describe the actual ingredient rather than using the term probiotic without further explanation. The detailed criteria are covered in the Labtree article on cosmetic claims in the EU.
What does microbiome-friendly mean, and how is it proven?
There is no legal definition for this term. It is common practice to provide evidence that the finished product does not significantly inhibit relevant strains of the skin flora in vitro, supplemented by an in-use study with swabs taken before and after application. The test design and claims are aligned with each other prior to the study.
Can scalp care samples be tested before budget approval?
Yes. Samples of pre-qualified Labtree formulations are typically dispatched within 24 hours, and standard sample shipping is free of charge. For scalp care, it is worthwhile evaluating the spray pattern, drying time, and residue at the hairline before budget is released for customization and testing. Why early physical samples make decisions more reliable is described in the Labtree article on sampling before budget approval.
How long does it take to develop a scalp serum?
At Labtree, a customized white-label formulation with standard packaging is typically ready for delivery in 2 to 3 months, while a new private-label development usually takes 3 to 6 months. For a scalp care line, a planned efficacy or microbiome study on the finished product will particularly extend the timeline, as it can only begin with the final formulation.
What is the minimum quantity for a scalp care line, and who owns the formulation?
At Labtree, the minimum order quantity is generally 1,500 units per product, depending on the product type, fill size, and packaging. With white label, the formulation remains with Labtree; with a private label new development, formulation rights or exclusivity can be contractually transferred to the brand.






