Having mascara produced: formulation, brush, and preservation

Having mascara produced: formulation, brush, and preservation

05/29/26

8

Jorit Tessmann

Jorit Tessmann

CEO & Founder at Labtree GmbH

Anyone looking to have a mascara manufactured is deciding on a system consisting of formulation, brush, wiper, and bottle: the formulation base determines whether the mascara functions as waterproof, washable, or a tubing variant, while the brush and wiper together determine how much bulk is applied to the lashes. Because the product is applied around the eye contour and the brush is returned to the bottle after each use, stricter standards apply to preservation and microbiological quality than for most other make-up products.

This article shows the types of formulations available, which colorants and fibers are permitted around the eye area, which EU deadlines affect current mascara formulations, which testing is required prior to launch, and what influences the timeline and minimum order quantity.

The topic is short and compact

The formulation, brush, and wiper are sampled together, because it is the combination that determines the volume, length, or curl of a mascara.

Mascaras and other leave-on products containing D4, D5, or D6 in concentrations of 0.1% by weight or greater may no longer be placed on the market after June 6, 2027.

For the eye area, the SCCS guidelines in accordance with EN ISO 17516 specify a total viable count of no more than 1 x 10² CFU per g, and the preservative challenge test is conducted with the final formulation.

White-label products with standard packaging are typically ready for delivery from Labtree in 2 to 3 months, and private-label products in 3 to 6 months.

Several colorants listed in Annex IV are excluded for eye products, which is why each shade of a colored mascara is tested individually.

So läuft die Entwicklung bei Labtree

1

Konzeptionierung

2

Bemusterung – Standardmuster in 24 h

3

Individualisierung

4

Prototyping

5

Produktion

White Label 2–3 Monate · Private Label 3–6 Monate · Produktion ab 1.000 Stück

How do effect type, formulation, and brush relate to each other?

The effect type is the first decision, because it determines both the formulation and the applicator at the same time. A brush that delivers good results on a volume base can clump or pick up too little bulk on a low-viscosity definition base. Formulation and brush are therefore sampled together, not selected one after the other.

  • Volume: higher solids content made of waxes and pigment, dense bristles or comb structures that pick up a lot of bulk. Clumping and drying in the wiper neck are critical.

  • Length: film formers that make the lash tips appear elongated, often supplemented by short fibers; brushes with separating bristles.

  • Curl: film formers that shrink upon drying and lift the lash, frequently with a curved brush; the durability of the curl depends on the film hardness.

  • Definition: lower viscosity, fine bristles or silicone brushes with short nubs for separated lashes.

Waxes shape structure, shine, and build-up. According to an overview report by the Tear Film & Ocular Surface Society (TFOS), 60 percent of commercial mascaras contain carnauba wax; the same report also identifies carnauba wax as a potential trigger of eyelid contact dermatitis. For concepts with skin compatibility claims, the wax system is therefore aligned early on with the safety assessment. How film formers and durability interact in long-wearing eye makeup is also described in the article Developing Long-Wear Makeup.

Waterproof, washable, or tubing: which formulation base is right?

The choice of base determines durability, removability, and the production process. Three basic types are common:

Base

Structure

Technical limitation

Washable emulsion

Wax-in-water emulsion with pigments and water-dispersible film formers

High water activity, thus highest preservation requirement

Waterproof

Anhydrous or low-water base based on volatile hydrocarbons or silicones with waxes

Solvent selection, odor, drying in the vial, more complex removal

Tubing

Film-forming polymer dispersion that forms a film around each lash

Film formation and removal with warm water must be balanced together

Waterproof bases have a disadvantage that brands should evaluate for their target group: According to the TFOS Report, waterproof mascaras and eyeliners require stronger eye makeup removers, which can put additional strain on the ocular surface. For concepts focusing on sensitive eyes, a tubing or emulsion base is therefore often the more logical choice.

Deadline for cyclic silicones

Existing waterproof formulations with cyclopentasiloxane (D5) or cyclohexasiloxane (D6) as a volatile carrier must be reviewed. According to Regulation (EU) 2024/1328, D4, D5, and D6 shall not be placed on the market in leave-on cosmetic products in a concentration equal to or greater than 0.1% by weight after June 6, 2027 (Annex XVII, entry 70, paragraph 3, point (b) REACH). Switching to another volatile carrier alters drying time, viscosity, and interaction with the brush, and requires new stability and skin compatibility data.

Which dyes and fibers are permitted in the eye area?

Colorants in cosmetic products must be listed in Annex IV to Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 (Article 14(1)(c)). For mascara, the column on the scope of application is crucial: The preamble to Annexes II to VI defines eye products as products intended for application in the vicinity of the eyes, and several colorants carry the note "Not to be used in eye products", such as CI 15510 or CI 74260. A shade that works in an eyeshadow or lip product is therefore not automatically permitted for a colored mascara.

  • Black: Carbon black (CI 77266) is listed in Annex IV with purity criteria; alternatively, black iron oxide (CI 77499) is used, which is easier to disperse, but provides less intense coverage.

  • Brown and brown-black: Mixtures of iron oxides; the shade is adjusted via the quantitative ratio and tested against a standard sample per batch.

  • Colored variants: Each colorant is individually tested for its authorization for eye products. If a range of shades is marketed, Article 19(1)(g) allows a common list of ingredients using the symbol "+/-".

Fibers and microplastics restriction

Lengthening mascaras frequently contain synthetic fibers, such as those made of nylon. The TFOS report documents a case report in which 1 mm long nylon fibers from a fiber mascara became embedded in the conjunctiva and triggered inflammation. Regulating this further is Regulation (EU) 2023/2055 on synthetic polymer microparticles: For make-up products, which according to the definition explicitly include eyelashes, the prohibition on placing on the market does not apply until October 17, 2035 (Annex XVII Entry 78 paragraph 6(c) REACH). From October 17, 2031 to October 16, 2035, such products must bear the statement "This product contains microplastics." (paragraph 9). Whether a fiber or a polymer powder falls under the definition is checked for each raw material using supplier specifications; for new formulations, it is advisable to also test alternatives already during sampling.

Why is preservation especially critical for mascara?

With each use, the brush introduces germs from the eyelashes and eyelid margin back into the tube. The TFOS report cites a study in which, after three months of use, microorganisms were detectable in over 35 percent of mascaras that were each used by only one person; the microbial load increases with frequency of use, age of the product, and number of users. The same report describes that the comparatively high water activity of mascara promotes microbial growth.

Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 requires in Annex I Part A that the safety report contain the microbiological quality and the results of the preservation challenge test; products applied in the vicinity of the eyes require special attention here. The SCCS Notes of Guidance (12th Revision) assign eye area products to Category 1, with these limits according to EN ISO 17516:

  • total aerobic mesophilic microorganism count of at most 1 x 10² CFU per g or ml (Category 2: 1 x 10³),

  • absence of Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Staphylococcus aureus, and Candida albicans in 1 g or 1 ml.

For the preservation challenge test, the SCCS identifies Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Staphylococcus aureus, Candida albicans, and Aspergillus brasiliensis as test organisms. There is no statutory test method; in practice, the test is generally carried out according to ISO 11930, specifically with the final formulation. Any subsequent change to wax, film formers, or pigment content can alter the efficacy of the preservative system and necessitate a retest.

What the regulation specifies regarding preservatives

Preservatives must be listed in Annex V. Mercury compounds such as thiomersal are only permitted there for eye products up to 0.007 percent (calculated as Hg) and must be labelled with "Contains thiomersal"; they are generally not used for new concepts. For a minimum shelf life exceeding 30 months, according to Art. 19(1)(c), the period of use after opening is indicated with the open jar symbol; this period is derived from stability and preservation data of the specific formulation in the specific tube.

Which tests and documentation are required before the launch?

For a mascara, a defined scope of testing results from the formulation, packaging material, and claim, which should be completed before production release:

  1. Stability in the original container: Viscosity, drying in the bottle neck, wiper behavior, and phase separation under elevated temperature and during cycling. Mascara is sensitive to water loss via the thread.

  2. Compatibility of bulk and packaging material: Solvent-containing waterproof bases are tested for swelling or stress cracking on the container and wiper.

  3. Preservation efficacy test with the final formulation as well as microbiological testing of each batch; the SCCS considers the routine microbiological analysis of each batch placed on the market to be necessary.

  4. Skin compatibility: Because animal testing for cosmetic products is prohibited under Art. 18 of the Regulation, the assessment relies on raw material data, in vitro methods, and, depending on the claim, in-use tests on humans under specialist medical supervision.

  5. Evidence for advertising claims: Claims such as "waterproof", "suitable for contact lens wearers", or "ophthalmologically tested" must be supported by adequate and verifiable evidence according to the substantiation criterion of Regulation (EU) No 655/2013, which is relevant to the product and the claimed benefit.

Which tests in general must be completed prior to a launch is classified in the article Stability and Safety Testing for Cosmetics; permissible phrasing for advertising claims is covered in Cosmetic Advertising Claims in the EU.

What do the brush, wiper, and sleeve determine during filling?

With mascara, the packaging also plays a decisive role in the result. The inner diameter of the wiper determines how much bulk remains on the brush; a wiper that is too tight makes a volume formulation flat, while one that is too wide leaves clumps on the brush head. Brush shape, brush type (injection-molded plastic or elastomer brush, or twisted wire brush with fibers), and stem length are therefore evaluated with the laboratory bulk in the final bottle with the final wiper, not in arbitrary sample bottles.

Typical filling limits

  • Viscosity and structure buildup: Mascara bulks are pasty and build up structure after shearing. Filling must introduce the bulk into the narrow bottle without air pockets; air leads to drying out and clumping.

  • Volatile components: With waterproof bases, solvent evaporates during filling, which can alter viscosity and filling weight; the filling temperature and the holding time of the bulk material are therefore limited.

  • Filling quantity and residual quantity: The brush displaces volume upon insertion; nominal filling volume and achievable emptying are determined by the combination of bottle, wiper, and brush.

Standard brushes and standard bottles are usually available more quickly than custom brushes for which tools must be adapted. The minimum order quantities of the component manufacturers are therefore often a stronger driver of the project volume than the bulk material itself; these relationships are explained in the article MOQ in cosmetics.

How long does a mascara project take, and what does the quantity depend on?

How long does a mascara project take, and what does the quantity depend on?

How long does a mascara project take, and what does the quantity depend on?

Labtree is a B2B cosmetics developer and cosmetics manufacturer with its own laboratory and production capacities in Germany. For mascara as well, Labtree covers formulation development, in-house laboratory work, sampling, manufacturability testing, and cosmetics production including filling, turning concepts into laboratory samples, manufacturable formulations, and finished products. In terms of timeline, two paths must be distinguished:

  • White Label: The brand adopts a tested Labtree formulation, such as a volume mascara, and customizes it specifically. With standard packaging, this is typically ready for delivery in 2 to 3 months; the formulation remains the property of Labtree.

  • Private Label: The formulation is developed from scratch according to the brand's requirements, such as a tubing base or a waterproof variant without cyclic silicones. It usually takes 3 to 6 months to reach market readiness; formulation rights or exclusivity can be contractually transferred to the brand.

Samples of pre-qualified formulations typically leave the sample warehouse within 24 hours, allowing effect, brush, and drying time to be assessed early on the real product. The minimum order quantity is generally 1,500 units per product, depending on product type, filling size, and packaging. What extends the timeline in individual cases is usually not the formulation, but the availability of custom brushes and casings, as well as the duration of stability testing and preservative efficacy testing. If you are also planning an eyeliner, you will find format-specific questions in the article Eyeliner produzieren lassen.

Quellen

FAQ

Who owns the mascara formulation?

That depends on the service model. With white label, the brand adopts a tested formulation from the manufacturer, and the formulation remains with the manufacturer. With private label, the formulation is newly developed for the brand, and rights or exclusivity are contractually agreed upon. Read more in the magazine article Confidentiality with the contract manufacturer: NDA and formulation ownership.

Does a waterproof mascara need to be reformulated due to the D5 restriction?

If it contains D4, D5, or D6 in a concentration of 0.1% by weight or more, yes: For leave-on cosmetic products, the restriction under Regulation (EU) 2024/1328 applies after June 6, 2027. Replacing the volatile carrier alters drying and viscosity and requires new stability and skin compatibility data, which is why the transition should be planned with sufficient lead time.

Can fiber mascaras still be sold after the microplastics restriction?

For make-up products, including eyelash products, the ban under Regulation (EU) 2023/2055 will not apply until October 17, 2035. From October 17, 2031, to October 16, 2035, products containing synthetic polymer microparticles must bear the notice "This product contains microplastics." Whether a specific fiber falls under the definition is checked for each raw material based on supplier information.

Can a mascara be advertised as promoting eyelash growth?

Mascara is a cosmetic product and may address the appearance and condition of eyelashes, such as making them look more conditioned or stronger. Claims regarding growth could be interpreted as indicating a pharmacological effect and classify the product as a medicinal product; they should therefore be avoided. According to Regulation (EU) No. 655/2013, any care claim must be supported by adequate evidence.

Can mascara be made without preservatives?

For water-based emulsion and tubing bases, a preservation system is generally required because the brush introduces germs into the tube with each use. Anhydrous bases have lower water activity, but their microbiological stability must also be substantiated in the safety report. The results of the preservative challenge test with the final formulation are decisive.

What documents does a mascara need before being sold in the EU?

A Responsible Person, a Cosmetic Product Safety Report pursuant to Annex I of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, a Product Information File, and a CPNP notification prior to placing on the market are required. For mascara, this includes microbiological data, the challenge test, and checking that every colorant is approved for eye cosmetics. The procedures are described in the magazine article on the EU Cosmetics Regulation in practice.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get more helpful information about cosmetics development.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get more helpful information about cosmetics development.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get more helpful information about cosmetics development.

Contact us!

>