The topic is short and compact
Anionic surfactants are considered powerful cleansers and foamers, but more irritating; amphoteric and nonionic co-surfactants reduce their potential for irritation.
The skin's surface has a pH of 4.0 to 6.0, soaps range from 8.5 to 11.0, and modern syndets achieve 5.0 to 5.5.
The format changes the safety assessment: the SCCS uses a retention factor of 0.01 for shower gel and 0.10 for makeup remover.
Cleaning products placed on the market from August 1, 2026, must comply with extended allergen labeling requirements; the threshold is set at 0.01% for rinse-off products.
Salicylic acid is permitted up to 2.0% in a facial cleanser, and up to 0.5% (as acid) as a preservative.
So lรคuft die Entwicklung bei Labtree
1
Konzeptionierung
2
Bemusterung โ Standardmuster in 24 h
3
Individualisierung
4
Prototyping
5
Produktion
White Label 2โ3 Monate ยท Private Label 3โ6 Monate ยท Produktion ab 1.000 Stรผck
Which surfactant system is right for which facial cleanser?
The surfactant system determines how strongly a cleanser degreases and how heavily it stresses the stratum corneum. A review on soaps and syndets (Mijaljica et al., Molecules 2022) describes the mechanisms: surfactants can denature and swell stratum corneum proteins, dissolve the body's own lipids such as ceramides, cholesterol, and fatty acids, and wash out components of the natural moisturizing factor. Anionic surfactants are considered powerful cleansers and foaming agents, but also highly irritating; non-ionic surfactants cleanse more gently and generally have the lowest irritation potential; amphoteric surfactants fall somewhere in between.
Sulfate surfactants (Sodium Laureth Sulfate, Sodium Lauryl Sulfate): inexpensive, high-foaming, easily thickened with salt. For products positioned for sensitive skin, the irritation threshold is the bottleneck.
Isethionates (Sodium Cocoyl Isethionate): creamy foam, mild skin feel. The raw material has poor water solubility and is usually incorporated under heat, which lengthens the manufacturing process.
Amino acid surfactants (glutamates, glycinates, sarcosinates): mild and easy to communicate, but more expensive as a raw material. They hardly thicken with salt and therefore usually require a polymer as a thickener.
Alkyl polyglucosides (Coco-Glucoside, Decyl Glucoside): non-ionic, very mild, but with lower foam volume and an inherent pH in the supply form that must be readjusted in the formulation.
Amphoteric co-surfactants (Cocamidopropyl Betaine, Amphoacetates): stabilize the foam and lower the irritation potential of the primary anionic surfactants.
In practice, a facial cleanser almost always consists of a primary surfactant and one to three co-surfactants. According to the same review, combining anionic with non-ionic and amphoteric surfactants lowers the irritation potential of the anionic component. Formulation work consists of balancing the total active content, mixing ratio, and thickening in such a way that foam, viscosity, and skin feel remain stable throughout the entire shelf life.
What pH value is ideal for a facial cleanser?
For a daily facial cleanser, a slightly acidic to neutral pH range is the typical target corridor. The review by Mijaljica et al. reports the pH of the skin surface as 4.0 to 6.0, classic soaps at 8.5 to 11.0, conventional syndets at 5.5 to 7.0, and newer syndets based on sulfosuccinates and acyl isethionates at 5.0 to 5.5. Above pH 8, skin proteins swell significantly more.
Where the pH value is technically limited
Surfactant solubility: Some amino acid surfactants lose solubility and foaming performance at acidic values. A very low target pH can therefore restrict the choice of surfactants.
Preservation: Organic acids such as benzoic acid and sorbic acid are sufficiently effective only in their undissociated form, that is, in the acidic range. Therefore, the pH and preservation system are determined together.
pH drift: The pH value can shift during storage, for example due to the hydrolysis of esters or interactions with fragrances. It is therefore measured at every test point during stability testing.
Anyone wishing to claim "pH skin neutral" or state a specific pH value on the packaging needs the measured value from the finished product throughout its entire shelf life, not just from a fresh laboratory sample.
Gel, foam, cream or micellar water: what difference does the format make?
The format determines viscosity, surfactant concentration, packaging material, and the exposure assumption in the safety report. It should therefore be decided before the first sampling, not just during packaging selection.
Format | Technical basis | Typical limitation |
|---|---|---|
Cleansing gel | Surfactant solution with salt or polymer thickening | Viscosity must match the dispenser pump or tube; salt thickening works poorly with mild surfactants |
Foam from a foam dispenser | low-viscosity surfactant solution without thickener | The dispenser's mesh and mixing chamber only tolerate very low viscosity; dispensers limit fill volume and sourcing |
Cleansing cream or milk | Emulsion with low surfactant content | Emulsion stability and preservation are more complex than with gel |
Micellar water | low-concentration, very mild surfactants in aqueous phase | is often not rinsed off, which changes the exposure assumption |
Micellar water shows why the format matters regulatorily. The SCCS Notes of Guidance (12th Revision, SCCS/1647/22) calculate a retention factor of 0.01 for shower gel, 0.10 for make-up remover, and 1.00 for face cream. For a make-up remover that partly remains on the skin, the safety assessment therefore calculates with ten times the retention factor of a rinse-off gel. This increases the calculated exposure to preservatives and fragrances and reduces the margin of safety determined by the safety assessor for these substances.
Oil- and wax-based cleansers follow their own logic using emulsifiers instead of classic surfactants; they are described in the article Having Cleansing Balm Produced.
Which active ingredients are useful in a rinse-off product?
A facial cleanser stays on the skin only briefly and is rinsed off. active ingredients in a rinse-off product therefore primarily support the skin feel and positioning; efficacy claims must be substantiated on the finished product in actual use.
Soothing and nourishing additives (panthenol, allantoin, glycerin, niacinamide): formulation-wise uncritical, as long as they do not alter viscosity and foam. Glycerin in higher dosages can dampen foam volume.
Salicylic acid for cleansers for impure skin: According to Regulation (EU) 2019/1966 on Annex III entry 98 and Annex V entry 3 of the Cosmetics Regulation, salicylic acid is permitted in products such as facial cleansers up to 2.0% when not used as a preservative, and up to 0.5% (acid) as a preservative. It is classified as a Category 2 CMR substance and can cause serious eye damage; for a cleanser used near the eyes, this must be taken into account in warning labels and safety assessments. Formulation aspects are explored in depth in the article having BHA serum manufactured.
Fruit acids and enzymes: require a low pH or a protected delivery form and are sensitive to surfactants and temperature. Their stability is tested separately over the shelf life.
For the product range, a lean active ingredient concept with two to three clearly justified additives is easier to substantiate, stabilize, and calculate than a long list of low-dose trend ingredients.
What testing does a facial cleanser need before launch?
Prior to being placed on the market, every facial cleanser requires a safety report pursuant to Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, Art. 10 and Annex I. Part A of Annex I requires, among other things, information on stability under reasonably foreseeable storage conditions (No. 2), microbiological quality including the results of the preservation challenge test (No. 3), relevant characteristics of the packaging material (No. 4), and exposure (No. 6). For products applied in the vicinity of the eyes, No. 3 requires special attention regarding microbiological quality.
What this specifically means for a cleanser
Stability: Viscosity, pH, appearance, odor, and foaming behavior are monitored at several storage temperatures over several weeks. Surfactant-rich gels tend to cloud or precipitate in the cold, while emulsions tend to undergo phase separation in the heat.
Preservation: Water-rich cleansers require a robust preservation challenge test, typically in accordance with ISO 11930. Plant extracts, proteins, and low surfactant concentrations, as in micellar water, increase the requirements.
Packaging compatibility: The product is tested in its final packaging. For foam dispensers, it is also important whether the foam quality and dosage amount remain consistent throughout storage.
Allergenic fragrance substances: With Regulation (EU) 2023/1545, the list of fragrance allergens that must be individually labeled in Annex III was expanded. The threshold is 0.01% in rinse-off products and 0.001% in leave-on products. Products that do not meet the amended requirements may only be placed on the market until July 31, 2026; goods placed on the market by then may continue to be made available on the market until July 31, 2028.
How stability testing and safety assessment dovetail in terms of timing is described in the article Stability and safety testing for cosmetics.
What advertising claims does a facial cleanser make?
For facial cleansers, advertising claims focus on mildness, skin compatibility, pH, and the absence of certain ingredients. The benchmark is the common criteria of Regulation (EU) No 655/2013.
Evidential support: Claims must be supported by adequate and verifiable evidence. Studies must be relevant to the product and the claimed benefit. Therefore, "for sensitive skin" or "dermatologically tested" requires data on the finished product, not just raw material data from the surfactant supplier.
Honesty: A cleanser must not claim unique properties that comparable products also possess. "With skin-neutral pH" is common among syndets and does not in itself constitute a unique selling proposition.
Fairness: Claims must not denigrate legally used ingredients. "Sulfate-free" must therefore be worded in a way that informs without presenting sulfate surfactants as harmful.
Which formulations stand up in the EU and which do not is outlined in the article Cosmetic advertising claims in the EU. It makes sense to include the planned claims in the briefing right from the start, as they influence the choice of surfactants, the testing scope, and the timeline.
Labtree is a B2B cosmetics developer and cosmetics manufacturer with its own laboratory and production capacities in Germany. For facial cleansers, this means: formulation development and surfactant adjustment in our own laboratory, sampling, feasibility testing, and production in a single project. The process follows the steps of conceptualization, sampling, customization, prototyping, and production. Samples of pre-qualified formulations typically leave the sample warehouse within 24 hours.
White Label: The brand adopts a finished, tested cleanser formulation and adapts it, for example in terms of fragrance or additives; the formulation remains with the manufacturer. Because the formulation has already been tested, development time is shortened; with standard packaging, White Label is typically ready for delivery in 2 to 3 months. Major changes to fragrance or additives may require separate stability tests.
Private Label: The formulation is developed from scratch according to the brand's requirements, with rights and exclusivity agreed contractually. Surfactant system, pH, and format can be freely defined, while stability and preservation testing begin anew.
Minimum Order Quantity: The minimum order quantity at Labtree is generally 1,500 units per product, depending on product type, filling size, and packaging.
What drives timeline and unit costs
The timeline is primarily determined by the number of sampling rounds, the duration of stability and preservation testing, and the delivery time of packaging materials; foam dispensers and custom-decorated bottles are often the longest lead-time items here. The unit costs depend on the surfactant system (amino acid surfactants and isethionates cost more than sulfate surfactants), active ingredient additives, packaging materials, and batch size. The page Have cosmetics developed shows the progression of a project.
Quellen
More useful links
FAQ
Who owns the formulation for a white-label facial cleanser?
With white label, the formulation remains with the manufacturer; the brand adopts a ready-made, tested formulation and customizes it. With private label, the formulation is newly developed according to the brand's requirements, with rights and exclusivity governed by contract. Details on this are covered in the Labtree magazine article "Confidentiality with the contract manufacturer: NDAs and formulation ownership".
Is micellar water considered a rinse-off or a leave-on product?
This depends on the intended use and is determined in the safety assessment. If the product is not rinsed off, it is likely to be classified as a leave-on product, and the labeling threshold for allergenic fragrances would then be 0.001% instead of 0.01%. The SCCS applies a retention factor of 0.10 for makeup removers.
What does the extended allergen labeling change for facial cleansers?
Regulation (EU) 2023/1545 has significantly expanded the list of fragrance allergens that must be individually labeled. Cleaning products that do not comply with the revised requirements may only be placed on the market until July 31, 2026; goods placed on the market before this date may remain available until July 31, 2028. For existing cleaning products, we recommend reviewing the fragrance composition with your perfume supplier.
Can a facial cleanser be advertised as sulfate-free?
Yes, if the statement is accurate and informative, without disparaging legally used ingredients. This is required by the fairness criterion in Regulation (EU) No 655/2013. If it becomes an efficacy claim, such as "especially gentle", evidence on the finished product is required.
Does a facial cleanser need human skin compatibility testing?
The Cosmetics Regulation does not mandate any specific human testing for cleansers; safety is assessed in the safety report based on ingredient data, exposure, and testing. However, anyone claiming "dermatologically tested" or "for sensitive skin" needs studies that are relevant to the product and the claimed benefit.
Can an existing facial cleanser be transferred to a new manufacturer?
Yes, provided that the formulation, raw material specifications, and test data are available and the brand owns the rights to them. The new manufacturer recreates the formulation in the laboratory, compares samples with the original, and checks feasibility on its equipment. The process is described in the Labtree magazine article "Changing cosmetics manufacturers: How a structured transition works".






