Manufacturing Eyeliner: Formats, Colorants, and Eye Safety

Manufacturing Eyeliner: Formats, Colorants, and Eye Safety

05/29/26

8

Jorit Tessmann

Jorit Tessmann

CEO & Founder at Labtree GmbH

Anyone looking to have an eyeliner produced first determines the format: liquid, felt-tip pen, gel, pencil, or kajal. The format determines the formulation base, pigment system, packaging, and scope of testing, and because eyeliner is an eye product, stricter standards apply to colorants, safety assessments, and preservation than to complexion products. The project becomes realistically plannable once the format, list of colorants, and packaging are established before sampling begins.

This article shows which formulation issues are typical for each format, which requirements of Regulation (EC) No. 1223/2009 apply to the eye area, and which stability and packaging tests must be completed before batch release.

The topic is short and compact

Liquid, felt-tip, gel, pencil, and kajal have different formulation bases and packaging, which is why choosing the format comes before sampling.

For eyeliner, the field of application column in Annex IV of the Cosmetics Regulation is what matters: some colorants are excluded for eye products or mucous membranes.

Carbon black in nano form is approved up to 10 percent, with primary particles of 20 nm or larger and over 97 percent purity, and is labeled in the INCI list as "(nano)".

Labtree's minimum order quantity is generally 1,500 units per product; for custom packaging, availability also influences the timeline.

With felt-tip pens, the formulation and tip form a system; stability tests are carried out in the final packaging and in various storage positions.

So läuft die Entwicklung bei Labtree

1

Konzeptionierung

2

Bemusterung – Standardmuster in 24 h

3

Individualisierung

4

Prototyping

5

Produktion

White Label 2–3 Monate · Private Label 3–6 Monate · Produktion ab 1.000 Stück

What types of eyeliner are there and what do they mean for the formulation?

Common eyeliner formats differ less in color than in their formulation base. This determines which manufacturing processes, packaging, and testing are required:

Format

Typical formulation base

Main technical risk

Packaging

Liquid eyeliner

aqueous pigment dispersion with film-forming agents

Sedimentation, viscosity drift

Bottle with dip brush

Felt-tip pen

low-viscosity dispersion that flows into the tip via capillary action

clogged or drying tip

Pen barrel with reservoir and fiber or felt tip

Gel eyeliner

anhydrous or solvent-based paste with high pigment content

Drying out in the jar after opening

Jar with tight seal, separate brush

Pencil

wax-oil core

Breakage, temperature-dependent hardness, sharpenability

Wooden pencil or mechanical twist-up

Kajal

soft wax-oil core for the waterline

Colorant approval for mucous membranes, skin compatibility

Wooden pencil or mechanical twist-up

The decision depends on how the brand's target audience uses the eyeliner. A felt-tip pen requires the closest alignment between formulation and packaging, as viscosity, particle size, and tip material must match. A pencil shifts the effort to lead manufacturing: the lead must be castable or extrudable, must not soften under heat, and must remain clean when sharpened.

How do you achieve a deep, even line?

A deep, uniform line results from pigment selection and, above all, from dispersion. For black, carbon black (CI 77266) and black iron oxides are the common colorants; brown and burgundy shades are mostly created from iron oxides. According to the SCCS opinion on carbon black in nano-form, typical use concentrations of carbon black in eyeliners, eye pencils, and eyeshadows are up to 10 percent.

Why dispersion determines the format

Agglomerates that are barely noticeable in a jar will clog the tip of a felt-tip pen or cause streaking in a liquid eyeliner. For this reason, the pigment is generally dispersed on a three-roll mill or in a bead mill as a pre-dispersion before being incorporated into the bulk base. For pencil leads, it is also essential that the pigment remains evenly distributed throughout the wax-oil matrix so that color payoff and hardness do not vary along the entire lead.

Color ranges

In a range with multiple shades, the colors do not behave identically: A black liquid eyeliner with a high carbon black content has a different rheology than a brown iron-oxide-based one. Testing should therefore include the shades that represent the extremes of the range, not just the primary shade.

Which color additives are approved for use in the eye area?

Only colorants listed in Annex IV of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 are permitted, and for eyeliner, the column "Field of application, body parts" applies there. Some colorants bear the note "Not to be used in eye products", others "Not to be used in products applied on mucous membranes". The preamble to Annexes II to VI defines an eye product as a product intended for application in the vicinity of the eyes, and expressly includes the edge of the eyelids among the mucous membranes.

For range planning, this means: A kohl pencil intended to be applied to the inner eyelid margin requires a list of colorants that is also permitted for mucous membranes. A shade that works as an eyeliner cannot automatically be advertised as a kohl pencil.

Carbon black in nano-form

Many carbon black grades consist of primary particles in the nano range. With Regulation (EU) 2016/1120, Carbon Black (nano) was included as a separate entry 126a in Annex IV: maximum 10 percent in ready-for-use preparations, primary particle size at least 20 nm, purity over 97 percent with a defined impurity profile, and no applications that may lead to inhalation. According to Article 19(1)(g) of the Cosmetics Regulation, the name of an ingredient in the form of a nanomaterial in the list of ingredients must be followed by the word "nano" in brackets. For purchasing specifications, it is therefore advisable to request the particle size distribution and the purity profile from the raw material supplier before the formulation is finalized.

For shade ranges, Article 19(1)(g) allows all colorants in the palette to be listed with the addition "may contain ..." or "+/-". This simplifies packaging and labeling when several shades use the same folding box.

How are drying time and durability on the skin adjusted?

Drying time and wear time on the skin are adjusted via the ratio of volatile components, film formers, and waxes. With liquid and felt-tip liners, water or a volatile solvent evaporates, leaving behind a polymer film, such as one made of acrylate copolymers, which fixes the pigments to the skin. Gel eyeliners often use volatile hydrocarbons or silicones so that the line remains workable briefly and then sets. Pencils and kajal do not dry in the strict sense; their adhesion comes from waxes, oils, and the hardness of the core.

The Trade-off

Fast drying and waterproof properties conflict with workability and removability. A film that sets too quickly will also dry out in the tip of a felt-tip pen. A waterproof film requires a suitable makeup remover and can cause more friction during removal. These compromises belong in the briefing: Should the eyeliner be waterproof, smudge-proof, or removable with warm water? Each variant changes the formulation base.

Durability is tested during sampling with application tests on the skin, abrasion tests, and wear tests over a defined period of time. How transfer-resistant films are structured is described in the article Developing Long-Wear Makeup.

What does the safety assessment require for eye products?

The safety assessment of an eyeliner requires more attention than for many other make-up products. Annex I Part A No. 3 of the Cosmetics Regulation explicitly mentions products applied near the eyes or on mucous membranes as cases that require special attention regarding microbiological quality, and requires the results of the preservation challenge test in the safety report. Methodologically, this test is generally carried out in accordance with ISO 11930.

Exposure and migration into the tear film

The SCCS Notes of Guidance (12th Revision) assume a daily applied amount of 0.005 g, an application area of 3.2 cm², and two applications per day for eyeliner. The amount is small, but the site is sensitive: A review on eye cosmetics and tear film summarizes that eyeliner applied along the inner lash line migrates faster and to a greater extent into the tear film than eyeliner on the external lid skin. In a pilot study, the maximum was reached within about ten minutes. The same review describes that pencil eyeliner can alter the properties of the lipid film at the eyelid margin and cites manufacturing, declining preservation during use, and shared products as sources of contamination.

For brands, this results in three key points: Kohl and inner lid claims require a formulation that is evaluated for this specific site of application. Water-based liquid and felt-tip formats require a preservation system that passes the challenge test and is well tolerated by the eyes. Claims such as "ophthalmologically tested" or "suitable for contact lens wearers" require sufficient, verifiable substantiation for that precise claim in accordance with Regulation (EU) No 655/2013; the article Cosmetic Claims in the EU outlines which evidence supports advertising claims.

What stability and packaging tests does an eyeliner need?

An eyeliner requires stability testing in the final sales packaging because the formulation and packaging function as a single system in felt-tip pens and jars. The Cosmetics Europe stability testing guidelines recommend testing in the material of the final packaging, testing each packaging type separately, choosing the smallest size if there are multiple sizes, and, if necessary, storing the product in different orientations, i.e. upright, inverted, and horizontal.

What this means for eyeliners

  • Felt-tip pen: Storage tip-up and tip-down, weight loss as a measure of drying out, color payoff after storage.

  • Liquid eyeliner: Sedimentation and viscosity over the storage period, skin compatibility of brush shaft and wiper with the formulation.

  • Gel eyeliner: Weight loss and surface drying in the jar, tightness of the closure.

  • Pencil and kajal: Break resistance and hardness under heat and cold, blooming of waxes on the lead surface, performance in temperature cycling tests.

The same guideline advises testing samples from batches produced with pilot-scale or production-scale equipment during development, as batch size and process affect stability. The shelf life labeling is also derived from the results: If the minimum durability exceeds 30 months, pursuant to Article 19(1)(c) of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, an indication of the date of minimum durability is not mandatory; instead, an indication of the period of time after opening for which the product can be used without any harm to the consumer is provided. The article Stability and Safety Testing for Cosmetics summarizes which tests must be completed prior to launch.

How does development work at Labtree?

How does development work at Labtree?

How does development work at Labtree?

Labtree is a B2B cosmetics developer and cosmetics manufacturer with its own laboratory and production capacities in Germany. Formulation development, in-house laboratory work, sampling, feasibility testing, and cosmetics production are thus located in one place; feasibility is already tested during development rather than only upon transfer to production scale. For an eyeliner, two service models are common:

  • White Label: A market-ready, tested Labtree formulation is specifically adapted for the brand, for example in its shade. With standard packaging, this is generally ready for delivery in 2 to 3 months; the formulation remains with Labtree.

  • Private Label: The formulation is newly developed according to the brand's requirements, such as for a waterproof felt-tip pen or a kohl pencil with a custom dye list. 3 to 6 months to market readiness is typical; formulation rights or exclusivity can be contractually transferred.

Samples of pre-qualified formulations are usually dispatched from the sample warehouse within 24 hours. The minimum order quantity is generally 1,500 units per product, depending on the product type, fill size, and packaging. Key time factors are the availability of raw materials and packaging materials, as well as the completion of stability tests; for custom-made pen barrels or tips, the packaging question must therefore be addressed right at the beginning. The process from conceptualization to production is described on the page Have cosmetics developed; how the applicator and formulation interact in related eye products is shown in the article Have mascara produced.

Quellen

FAQ

Can an eyeliner also be advertised as a kohl pencil for the waterline?

Only if the list of colorants and the safety assessment cover this area of application. The EU Cosmetics Regulation considers the waterline/eye margin to be a mucous membrane, and certain colorants in Annex IV are prohibited in products used on mucous membranes. Therefore, an eyeliner product cannot be marketed as a kohl without prior verification.

Does carbon black have to be labeled as nano in the INCI list?

Yes, if the quality used is a nanomaterial within the meaning of the regulation. In that case, the name in the list of ingredients is followed by the word "nano" in parentheses. Whether this applies is clarified by the raw material supplier's specifications regarding particle size and solubility.

Is a preservative-free eyeliner possible?

With anhydrous pencils and kajal, this is often possible because microorganisms rarely grow without free water. Water-based liquid and felt-tip formats generally require a preservative system. The critical factor is that the challenge test is passed and that the safety assessor evaluates the result in the safety report. A promotional claim such as "preservative-free" is subject to additional restrictions; this is covered in the Labtree article on cosmetic claims in the EU.

Who owns the formulation of an eyeliner?

That depends on the service model. With white label, the adapted standard formulation remains with the manufacturer; with private label, formulation rights or exclusivity can be contractually transferred to the brand. The Labtree article on confidentiality with the contract manufacturer explores these contractual questions in more detail.

Can an existing eyeliner formulation be transferred to a new manufacturer?

Yes, if the formulation, raw material specifications, and test documentation are available and the brand owns the rights to them. The new manufacturer verifies manufacturability on their equipment and typically repeats stability tests with batches from the new production run. The process is described in the Labtree article Changing cosmetics manufacturers.

What information does the manufacturer need for an initial eyeliner quote?

Helpful details include format, target shades, desired properties such as waterproof or washable, planned claims, packaging preferences, quantity per shade, and target price. The clearer the application area and packaging are defined, the more accurately the effort and timeline can be estimated. The Labtree article Inquiry to the Cosmetics contract manufacturer provides a complete list of these points.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get more helpful information about cosmetics development.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get more helpful information about cosmetics development.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get more helpful information about cosmetics development.

Contact us!

>