The topic is short and compact
A cleansing oil is a water-free rinse-off product made of an oil phase and an oil-soluble emulsifier; key considerations include oxidation, cold clarity, and leak-proof pumps.
Plant oils oxidize at different rates depending on their fatty acid and tocopherol profiles; choosing the right oil, adding tocopherols, and using light-protected bottles help slow down oxidation.
Choosing between PEG or PEG-free is a positioning decision; changing the emulsifier at a later stage requires rebalancing the oil phase and conducting new stability tests.
Products placed on the market after July 31, 2026, label fragrance allergens in accordance with Regulation (EU) 2023/1545, for rinse-off products starting at 0.01 percent.
Under Regulation (EU) No 655/2013, claims such as “removes waterproof sunscreen” require verifiable evidence for the finished product, usually in the form of an in-use test.
So läuft die Entwicklung bei Labtree
1
Konzeptionierung
2
Bemusterung – Standardmuster in 24 h
3
Individualisierung
4
Prototyping
5
Produktion
White Label 2–3 Monate · Private Label 3–6 Monate · Produktion ab 1.000 Stück
How does a cleansing oil work technically?
At its core, a cleansing oil consists of two components: an oil phase that dissolves lipid-soluble constituents such as sebum, film formers, and oil-soluble UV filters and lifts pigments from the makeup film, and an oil-soluble non-ionic emulsifier that remains dissolved in the oil until water is added. Only then does a milky oil-in-water emulsion form, which can be rinsed off along with the dissolved residues. The product is therefore a rinse-off product, even though it is applied to dry skin.
Compared to related cleansing formats, the requirements shift:
Cleansing Oil: liquid, clear, and anhydrous. Critical factors are clarity across the entire temperature range, oxidation of the oils, and pump tightness.
Cleansing Balm: contains wax or butter and is solid. Pouring temperature, cooling profile, and crystallization behavior are added as manufacturing parameters; details can be found in the article Having Cleansing Balm Manufactured.
Cleansing milk and gel: water-based, with surfactant system, pH control, and preservation; see Having Facial Cleansers Manufactured.
Because there is no water in the formulation, emulsion stability in the classic sense and pH measurement do not apply. Instead, oil quality, emulsifier solubility, and interactions with plastics and seals take center stage.
Which oil phase fits the positioning and price point?
The oil phase makes up the largest part of the formulation and determines sensory profile, dissolving power, and raw material costs. In practice, three raw material groups are combined:
Raw material group | Examples (INCI) | Strengths | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|
Plant oils | Helianthus Annuus Seed Oil, Oryza Sativa Bran Oil, Simmondsia Chinensis Seed Oil | Suitable for natural cosmetics, easy to communicate | Oxidation, odor drift, batch-to-batch variations of raw materials |
Esters | Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride, Ethylhexyl Palmitate, Isopropyl Myristate | Light spreading, consistent quality, low oxidation tendency | Can attack packaging materials and seals depending on the plastic |
Mineral oil | Paraffinum Liquidum | High dissolving power, very stable | Generally excluded for natural cosmetics, requires proof of refining quality |
Oxidation of plant oils
Plant oils with a high proportion of unsaturated fatty acids age oxidatively: peroxide value and odor increase, often before the product becomes visually noticeable. A storage study on commercial plant oils (Zaunschirm et al., Molecules 2018) demonstrates the mechanism: in transparent PET bottles at 22 °C and under alternating light and dark cycles, the peroxide value of sunflower oil rose to 24.7 meq O2/kg within 56 days, while the tocopherol content dropped by about 42 percent. Oils with a higher ratio of gamma- and delta- to alpha-tocopherol oxidized significantly more slowly, although the authors examined only one sample per oil type; tocopheryl acetate showed no antioxidant effect in the radical test.
For the formulation, this implies: oil selection based on fatty acid and tocopherol profile, an effective antioxidant such as tocopherol instead of tocopheryl acetate, a specification for the peroxide value at incoming goods inspection, and packaging that blocks light.
Mineral oil
Mineral oil is not banned in the EU, but it is subject to conditions. Annex II of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 lists numerous petroleum distillates as prohibited substances, unless the full refining history is known and it can be demonstrated that the substance from which it is produced is not a carcinogen. The BfR concludes in its Opinion No. 008/2018 that, according to current knowledge, no health risks are to be expected from highly refined mineral oils of pharmaceutical quality when applied to the skin, because mineral oil saturated hydrocarbons (MOSH) are hardly absorbed through the skin. Whether mineral oil is an option is therefore primarily a question of positioning.
PEG or PEG-free: Which emulsifier supports rinsing?
The emulsifier determines whether the oil emulsifies completely when rinsed off or leaves a greasy film behind. It must be clearly soluble in the oil and at the same time hydrophilic enough to form an emulsion spontaneously with water. The usage rate is adjusted on the laboratory sample against two objectives: complete rinsing and minimal eye stinging.
Ethoxylated emulsifiers (PEG): such as PEG-20 Glyceryl Triisostearate or Polysorbate 85. They emulsify reliably, remain clear in many oil blends, and are readily available as raw materials. Natural cosmetics standards generally exclude ethoxylated raw materials.
PEG-free emulsifiers: especially polyglycerol esters such as Polyglyceryl-4 Oleate or Polyglyceryl-10 Dioleate. They are suitable for natural cosmetic positioning, but require more fine-tuning: solubility depends more heavily on the oil blend, and some combinations turn cloudy in the cold or emulsify more slowly.
Solubilizers: small proportions of additional esters can improve clarity, but alter sensory profile and eye tolerance, and are also evaluated during stability testing.
The choice is a positioning decision, not a safety issue, as both routes can be implemented in compliance with EU regulations. Technically, it should be made early: changing the emulsifier at a later stage requires a rebalancing of the entire oil phase and invalidates ongoing stability tests.
How is the cleaning performance verified?
Claims such as “removes waterproof mascara” or “dissolves waterproof sunscreen” are advertising claims within the meaning of Regulation (EU) No 655/2013. According to the criterion of substantiation, they require sufficient and verifiable evidence; studies must be relevant to the product and the claimed benefit and be based on valid, reliable, and reproducible methods. Data from the emulsifier supplier regarding the raw material alone is not sufficient for this purpose, because anyone attributing properties of an ingredient to the finished product must also substantiate that.
Robust evidence is typically an in-use test on the finished product with human subjects: defined application of the target product, such as waterproof sunscreen or waterproof mascara, cleansing according to instructions for use, and determination of residues via standardized facial imaging with image analysis or using cotton pads. The test becomes meaningful when it is run against water and a comparator cleanser, and also assesses side effects such as skin tightness or stinging around the eyes. The stronger the claim, the larger the panel should be, as the evidentiary weight of the proof must be consistent with the type of claim according to the regulation.
For development, this means: The claim belongs in the briefing because it defines the testing scope. Anyone advertising with waterproof sunscreen or long-wearing makeup plans an in-use test with precisely these products, ideally against a comparator cleanser.
What testing does an anhydrous cleansing oil need?
Even an anhydrous oil requires a complete cosmetic product safety report in accordance with Article 10 and Annex I of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, including stability under reasonably foreseeable storage conditions. However, the focal points shift compared to an emulsion:
Stability and oxidation: Storage at elevated temperatures, in the cold, and under temperature cycling, as well as light exposure if the bottle is transparent. The Cosmetics Europe stability guidelines mention 37, 40, or 45 °C over one to several months as standard conditions and recommend light testing for products whose packaging allows light penetration. For cleansing oils, clarity, odor, and sensibly the peroxide value are also monitored.
Microbiology: The Guidelines on Annex I (Implementing Decision 2013/674/EU) distinguish between three categories. For products with low microbiological risk, such as those based on organic solvents or containing more than 20 percent alcohol, neither a preservative challenge test nor microbiological tests on the finished product are required, although a scientific justification is. The guidelines do not explicitly mention anhydrous oils. Whether a cleansing oil falls into this category must be justified in the safety assessment; relevant factors include the guidelines classifying plant-based raw materials as susceptible and the possibility that water might enter the bottle during use with wet hands.
Eye area: Makeup removers are used close to the eyes. Annex I requires particular attention to microbiological specifications for such products. Claims such as "also suitable for the eye area" are usually additionally supported by an in-use ophthalmological tolerance test.
An overview of the testing scope is described in the article Stability and Safety Testing for Cosmetics.
Which packaging materials are suitable and what are the filling limits?
A cleansing oil is low-viscosity and creeps along threads and sealing surfaces. Choosing the bottle, pump, and seal is therefore a distinct development step:
Pump: A lotion pump with a transport lock is common. Oils and esters can cause seals to swell; dripping pumps and oily bottle necks are typical causes for complaint. The pump is therefore stored with the final formulation, not with a preliminary stage.
Bottle material: Glass is chemically inert, but heavier and prone to breakage. PET is lightweight and transparent, yet allows light to pass through, which can accelerate oxidation in formulations rich in vegetable oils. Tinted or coated material reduces this risk.
Testing in the final container: The Cosmetics Europe stability guidelines recommend testing in the identical packaging material, testing the smallest size if there are multiple sizes, and also storing the product horizontally or upside down. For oil, horizontal storage in particular provides meaningful information regarding leak tightness.
Filling: Low-viscosity oils can be cold-filled, but tend to drip at the filling nozzle. Filling volume, headspace, and capping torque are determined during prototyping on the filling line.
The guidelines for the safety report also require evaluating the relevant properties of the packaging material, because substances from the packaging material can migrate into the formulation. This point requires particular attention with oil-containing formulations, as oils can absorb lipophilic components from plastics.
A cleansing oil is rinsed off and, when labeling allergenic fragrances, counts as a rinse-off product. Under Regulation (EU) 2023/1545, significantly more fragrance allergens must be individually indicated in the list of ingredients as soon as they exceed 0.01 percent in rinse-off products; for leave-on products, the threshold is 0.001 percent. Products that do not meet the new requirements could only be placed on the market until July 31, 2026, and may be made available on the market until July 31, 2028. For new cleansing oils, the extended list therefore applies from the time they are first placed on the market.
Anyone aiming for a fragrance-free product or a short INCI list decides this before selecting the fragrance, because every allergen subject to labeling appears on the label. Essential oils also contain such substances.
Regarding shelf life: According to Article 19(1)(c) of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, the date of minimum durability must only be indicated for a minimum durability of up to 30 months; beyond that, the period after opening is stated. For formulations rich in vegetable oils, oxidation usually determines what period is reliable. In accordance with Article 11, the responsible person keeps the product information file with all test reports for ten years after the last batch has been placed on the market.
Labtree is a B2B cosmetics developer and cosmetics manufacturer from Hamburg with its own laboratory and production capacities in Germany. For a cleansing oil, Labtree covers formulation development, in-house laboratory work, sampling, manufacturability testing, and cosmetics production. Two service models are available:
White Label: The brand adopts a finished, tested Labtree formulation and customizes it specifically. The formulation remains the property of Labtree. With standard packaging, the product is generally ready for delivery in 2 to 3 months. The considerations are described in the article White Label Cosmetics: Advantages and Limitations.
Private Label: The formulation is developed from scratch according to the brand's requirements, for example with a PEG-free emulsifier system and a specified selection of oils. Typically, 3 to 6 months should be expected until market readiness; formulation rights and exclusivity are regulated by contract.
Samples of pre-qualified formulations are usually dispatched from the sample warehouse within 24 hours, allowing the sensory profile and rinse-off behavior to be evaluated early on with the actual product. The process follows the steps of conceptualization, sampling, customization, prototyping, and production. The minimum order quantity is generally 1,500 units per product, depending on the product type, fill size, and packaging; what determines minimum quantities is explained in MOQ in Cosmetics.
Quellen
More useful links
FAQ
Does a cleansing oil need a preservative?
Not necessarily. Water-free formulations offer microorganisms little basis for growth, but classification as a low microbiological risk product must be scientifically justified in the safety report. Plant-based raw materials and use with wet hands are factored into this assessment.
Who owns the formulation of a cleansing oil?
With white label, the formulation remains with the manufacturer, while the brand customizes it. In the case of a new development under private label, formulation rights or exclusivity can be contractually transferred to the brand. The magazine article “Confidentiality with the contract manufacturer: NDA and formulation ownership” delves deeper into this topic.
Can a cleansing oil be certified as natural cosmetics?
Yes, if the oil phase and emulsifier meet the criteria of the chosen standard. As a rule, mineral oil and ethoxylated emulsifiers are ruled out, while PEG-free polyglycerol esters are suitable. The certifiability of the raw materials should be verified before sampling, not after.
Why does a cleansing oil turn cloudy?
Common causes include an emulsifier precipitating out of the oil phase at low temperatures, or water getting into the bottle during use. Freeze-thaw and temperature cycling tests during stability testing reveal the first issue prior to launch. The second can be mitigated using a pump dispenser and clear usage instructions.
Is mineral oil still permitted in cleansing oils?
Yes, provided it complies with the requirements of the Cosmetics Regulation—meaning the refining process is known and the starting material is proven to be non-carcinogenic. According to current knowledge, the BfR (German Federal Institute for Risk Assessment) does not anticipate any health risks from highly refined, pharmaceutical-grade mineral oils used on the skin. Whether mineral oil suits a brand depends on its positioning.
What does the new allergen labeling change for existing cleansing oils?
Products that do not meet the extended requirements and were placed on the market by July 31, 2026, may still be made available until July 31, 2028. Batches placed on the market since August 1, 2026, require an updated list of ingredients and, if necessary, new labels. The allergen declaration from the fragrance supplier indicates which allergens the scent contains.






