The topic is short and compact
Candelilla, sunflower, and carnauba wax melt between approximately 67 and 84 °C; the chosen texturizing agent determines the balm's heat stability, hardness, and filling temperature.
The emulsifier determines whether it rinses off without leaving an oily residue and must be tested against the types of makeup the balm is actually intended to remove.
Even without an aqueous phase, stability, microbiology, and packaging compatibility must be included in the safety report; a stricter microbiological limit applies to the eye area.
The pouring temperature and cooling profile for hot filling are determined during prototyping because they can cause cracks, craters, and graininess in the jar.
As a rinse-off product, a balm must individually label fragrance allergens exceeding 0.01%; products placed on the market after July 31, 2026, must comply with the expanded list.
So läuft die Entwicklung bei Labtree
1
Konzeptionierung
2
Bemusterung – Standardmuster in 24 h
3
Individualisierung
4
Prototyping
5
Produktion
White Label 2–3 Monate · Private Label 3–6 Monate · Produktion ab 1.000 Stück
What is a cleansing balm from a manufacturer's perspective?
A cleansing balm is an anhydrous cleansing product with a semi-solid texture. It essentially consists of three components: an oil phase made of plant oils or esters that dissolves make-up, sunscreen residue, and sebum; a structuring agent made of waxes or plant butters that binds the oil; and an emulsifier system dissolved in the oil phase that forms a milky emulsion upon contact with water. Typically, an antioxidant for the oil phase and, if necessary, fragrance are added.
Legally, a cleansing balm is a rinse-off product. The Preamble to Annexes II to VI of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 defines it as a cosmetic product intended to be removed after application from the skin. This classification is more than just a formality: for rinse-off products, different limit values sometimes apply to preservatives and fragrance allergens compared to leave-on products.
Differentiation from related formats
Cleansing Oil: liquid, without structuring agents, usually in a bottle with a pump; the formulation is simpler, and hot-filling is not required (cold filling).
Aqueous facial cleanser: gel or foam based on surfactants with a water phase, pH control, and a preservative system.
Cleansing Balm: solid to semi-solid, hot-filled, usually in a jar; the challenge lies in crystallization, melting behavior, and rinse-off performance.
Anyone weighing oil against balm will find the liquid variant in the article Having cleansing oil produced, and the surfactant-based alternative under Having facial cleansers produced.
Which wax-oil base carries which texture?
The choice of structuring agent determines firmness, heat stability, and melting behavior. Plant waxes melt well above skin temperature: A review paper on plant wax oleogels cites approximately 67 to 73 °C for candelilla wax, around 75 °C for sunflower wax, and 79 to 84 °C for carnauba wax. The higher the melting range, the better the balm withstands warm storage and transport conditions, but the harder the texture becomes and the higher the filling temperature must be.
Structuring agent | Texture and behavior | Typical formulation problem |
|---|---|---|
Shea-butter-dominated base | soft, creamy, melts quickly on the skin | graininess due to post-crystallization, low heat stability |
Candelilla or sunflower wax | firmer structure, vegan | even small changes in quantity shift firmness significantly |
Carnauba wax (usually as a proportion) | increases firmness and heat stability | brittle structure, high filling temperature |
Beeswax | plastic, supple structure | not vegan, raw material quality varies with origin |
Low wax content (sorbet texture) | light, spoonable | oil separation when warm, limited packaging choices |
Oil binding does not depend solely on the amount of wax. The same review paper describes that small, evenly distributed wax crystals hold the oil better and that the cooling rate influences the crystal structure. For formulation development, this means: A texture that is stable in a beaker is only reliable once it has been reproduced with the subsequent cooling profile of the filling process. This is particularly relevant for shea-butter-rich formulations, as slowly cooling butter can tend toward a sandy texture in practice.
The oil phase also has a downside: oils with a high proportion of polyunsaturated fatty acids oxidize more quickly. A study of ten plant oils found during oxidation below 120 °C that oxidative stability increases with the proportion of saturated fatty acids and decreases with the proportion of polyunsaturated fatty acids; α-tocopherol had an antioxidant effect; however, the literature evaluated by the authors describes tocopherols in high amounts as pro-oxidative. Anyone wishing to promote an oil with a high linoleic acid content should therefore factor in an antioxidant and testing for odor changes.
How is the emulsifier system adjusted for rinsing off?
The emulsifier determines whether the balm forms a milky emulsion upon rinsing or leaves behind an oily film. Non-ionic, oil-soluble emulsifiers are used, such as PEG glyceride esters, polyglycerol esters, or sugar esters. Polyglycerol and sugar esters are often chosen when the brand relies on PEG-free or near-natural formulations; they generally require more fine-tuning because they behave differently in the wax-oil matrix.
Why this fine-tuning is so delicate is shown by a study on cleansing mechanisms on artificial skin: sebum was only emulsified in surfactant solutions at very low interfacial tension, whereas dimethicone, a typical component of color cosmetics such as lipstick and lip gloss, was removed exclusively by the detachment of oil droplets from the surface. For a balm, this means: performance must be tested against the products it is actually intended to remove, such as waterproof mascara, long-lasting foundation, or sunscreen.
What is tested in the laboratory
Rinsing behavior: Does the balm fully emulsify with a defined amount of water, and does a noticeable film remain after rinsing?
Solubility in fat: Does the emulsifier remain homogeneously dissolved in the matrix after cooling, or does cloudiness and blooming appear on the surface?
Cleansing performance: Comparison on test surfaces with defined make-up applications against a reference product.
sensory profile: Pick-up from the jar, glide during spreading, skin feel after rinsing.
More emulsifier improves rinsability, but shifts the sensory profile toward a gel and can worsen skin compatibility in the eye area. The appropriate proportion is determined by the formulation, not a rule of thumb.
Which tests does an anhydrous balm require?
Even without a water phase, the regulation requires full proof of safety. Annex I Part A of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 requires for the safety report, among other things, the stability under reasonably foreseeable storage conditions, the microbiological quality with particular attention to products used in the vicinity of the eyes, and the relevant characteristics of the packaging material.
Stability
The Cosmetics Europe Guidelines on Stability Testing mention, for accelerated testing, storage at 37, 40, or 45 °C over one, two, three, or more months depending on the product type, as well as temperature cycles and freeze-thaw tests that reveal certain weaknesses more quickly than constant storage. Testing is carried out in the same packaging material as used for sale, and if there are multiple sizes, preferably in the smallest container. For a balm, typical findings include oil separation on the surface, graininess, changes in hardness, and changes in color and odor.
Microbiology
Anhydrous formulations offer little habitat for microorganisms, but during use, water enters the jar via wet fingers. The SCCS Notes of Guidance (12th Revision) establish limits for the total viable count: a maximum of 100 CFU per gram for products specifically intended for the eye area, and a maximum of 1,000 CFU per gram for other products. Whether a preservation challenge test can be omitted is justified by a risk assessment according to ISO 29621, not by a blanket exemption due to the absence of water. If the balm is claimed as an eye makeup remover, the stricter category applies.
If the balm has a minimum durability of more than 30 months, the period of opening (PAO) must be included on the packaging in accordance with Article 19(1)(c) of the Regulation. The full scope of testing is described in the article on stability and safety testing for cosmetics.
What applies to fragrances and labeling?
Fragrance is a matter of consideration in facial cleansers because it affects skin compatibility in the eye area. From a regulatory perspective, the balm's classification as a rinse-off product helps: According to Annex III of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 as amended by Regulation (EU) 2023/1545, the extended list of allergenic fragrance substances must be individually listed in the ingredients list pursuant to Art. 19(1)(g) if they exceed 0.01% in rinse-off products; for leave-on products, the threshold is 0.001%. The transitional period for placing on the market expired on July 31, 2026: products that do not meet these requirements may no longer be placed on the market since that date; goods placed on the market prior to this may still be made available on the market until July 31, 2028.
The fact that the balm is rinsed off is also relevant for the safety assessment. The SCCS Notes of Guidance use a retention factor for this purpose, which takes rinsing and dilution into account in the exposure estimation. This lowers the calculated exposure, but does not replace ocular tolerance testing, as a cleansing balm is regularly used near the eyes.
Unscented version: simplifies labeling and claims, but makes the inherent scent of oils and waxes noticeable.
Scented version: request fragrance oil specifications with allergen levels early so that the label and INCI list do not have to be changed retroactively.
Marketing claims: claims such as "removes waterproof mascara" or "for sensitive eyes" require substantiation on the finished product.
The article Cosmetics Labeling: INCI, Mandatory Information, and Mistakes summarizes which mandatory details belong on the label.
What matters most for hot filling and jars?
A cleansing balm is filled hot: the bulk is heated above the melting range of the waxes, poured into the jar, and cooled under controlled conditions. Pouring temperature and cooling profile determine the appearance. If the surface cools too quickly, cracks, craters, or sunken centers will form; if it cools too slowly, the risk of coarse crystals and graininess increases. These parameters are defined during prototyping on the filling line and belong in the manufacturing instructions.
Packaging materials and their limits
Glass jars: withstand high filling temperatures and are inert to oils; heavier, fragile, and more expensive to transport.
Plastic jars (e.g., PP): lighter and more cost-effective; temperature resistance during filling and skin compatibility with the oil phase must be tested.
Tube or stick: only suitable for softer sorbet textures or very firm masses, respectively; the formulation must be tailored to the format.
Spatulas and inner lids: reduce water ingress from wet fingers and thus support the microbiological concept.
The Cosmetics Europe guideline recommends testing interactions in both directions: Does the packaging affect the product, and does the product attack the packaging? For oil-rich bulks, this affects items such as labels, seals, and printed surfaces. The minimum order quantities of jar suppliers are often the factor that determines the total volume of a project; how minimum quantities are structured is explained in MOQ in cosmetics explained.
The duration depends primarily on the service model. With white label, an existing, tested formulation from the manufacturer is adapted; the formulation remains with the manufacturer. With private label, the formulation is newly developed according to the brand's requirements, with rights and exclusivity regulated by contract. In both cases, the decisive time factors are the availability of raw materials and packaging materials, as well as the completion of stability testing.
Cost Drivers
Raw materials: Proportion and quality of plant butters, specialty waxes, and emulsifiers; certified or rare oils increase the price.
Packaging materials: Glass instead of plastic, decoration, spatulas, and outer cartons.
Filling: Hot filling requires heated systems and cooling time; this can reduce output per shift compared to cold filling.
Scope of testing: Stability, microbiology, packaging compatibility, and, if applicable, substantiation for eye or cleansing claims.
Labtree is a B2B cosmetics developer and cosmetics manufacturer from Hamburg with its own laboratory and production capacities in Germany. Formulation development, sampling, feasibility testing, and production are thus under a single responsibility. Samples of pre-qualified formulations are usually dispatched from the sample warehouse within 24 hours, and the shipment of standard samples is free of charge. White label with standard packaging is generally ready for delivery in 2 to 3 months; private label usually reaches market readiness in 3 to 6 months. The minimum order quantity is generally 1,500 units per product, depending on the product type, fill size, and packaging. The process from conception to production is described on the page Have cosmetics developed.
Quellen
More useful links
FAQ
What is the difference between cleansing balm and cleansing oil in terms of manufacturing?
A cleansing oil is liquid, contains no structuring agents, and is cold-filled into bottles. A balm requires waxes or butters, is hot-poured, and must remain stable in terms of crystallization and melting behavior. The Labtree article "Manufacturing Cleansing Oil" covers these differences in detail.
Does a waterless cleansing balm need a preservative?
Not necessarily. Whether preservatives and challenge testing can be dispensed with is determined by a documented risk assessment, for example in accordance with ISO 29621. Because water enters the jar during use, the safety assessment evaluates the realistic usage scenario and not just the formulation.
Can a cleansing balm be advertised as an eye makeup remover?
Yes, if the claim is substantiated on the finished product. A product specifically intended for the eye area falls into the stricter microbiological category with a maximum of 100 CFU per gram. In addition, ocular tolerance should be part of the testing concept.
Can a cleansing balm be formulated to be vegan or natural?
Yes. Instead of beeswax, candelilla, sunflower, or carnauba wax can be used, for example, and PEG-free polyglycerol or sugar esters are suitable as emulsifiers. Natural content can be calculated according to ISO 16128; certification labels have their own lists of raw materials, which should be clarified prior to formulation development.
What applies after the transition period for fragrance allergens expires?
With Regulation (EU) 2023/1545, the list of fragrance allergens that must be individually labeled has been significantly expanded. As of August 1, 2026, products may only be placed on the market with the extended labeling; goods placed on the market before this date may continue to be made available until July 31, 2028. For rinse-off products such as a balm, a threshold of more than 0.01% applies.
Who owns the formulation of a cleansing balm?
With white label, the adapted standard formulation remains the property of the manufacturer. With private label, the formulation is newly developed for the brand; formulation rights or exclusivity can be transferred contractually. This should be stipulated in the quotation before the project starts.
What is the minimum order quantity for a cleansing balm at Labtree?
The minimum order quantity is generally 1,500 units per product. The exact quantity depends on the product type, fill size, and packaging; in addition, the jar supplier's minimum order requirements may determine the overall project volume.






