Having Body Butter Produced: Lipid Base, Texture, and Jars

Having Body Butter Produced: Lipid Base, Texture, and Jars

June 4th, 2026

8

Jorit Tessmann

Jorit Tessmann

CEO & Founder at Labtree GmbH

Anyone looking to have a body butter manufactured determines four points early on: the lipid base, the formulation type (anhydrous, W/O emulsion, or whipped), the cooling and filling profile, and the packaging material. These decisions determine whether the product remains smooth in the jar or becomes grainy, how complex preservation is, and which tests are required prior to market launch. How long development takes depends primarily on whether an already tested formulation is adapted or developed from scratch.

This article is aimed at product management, purchasing, and founding teams. It describes the typical formulation challenges of a body butter, the limitations of common packaging materials, and the documentation required under Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009.

The topic is short and compact

Raw shea butter melts at around 32 °C; the firmness of a body butter can be customized using olein and stearin fractions or liquid oils.

Refined shea butter has less odor and is more resistant to oxidation, but it loses tocopherols, which is why the lipid phase often requires an added antioxidant.

Graininess is usually caused by uncontrolled crystallization; cooling rate and filling temperature should therefore be included in the manufacturing instructions for each batch.

Stability is tested in the final jar using temperature cycles, as packaging materials, migration, and repeated surface melting can alter the texture.

Even an anhydrous body butter in a jar requires challenge testing and microbiological analysis, or a scientifically justified low-risk classification.

So läuft die Entwicklung bei Labtree

1

Konzeptionierung

2

Bemusterung – Standardmuster in 24 h

3

Individualisierung

4

Prototyping

5

Produktion

White Label 2–3 Monate · Private Label 3–6 Monate · Produktion ab 1.000 Stück

Which lipid base is suitable for which product profile?

The lipid base determines hardness, melting behavior upon application, inherent odor, and raw material costs. Shea butter is the most common base because it is solid at room temperature and melts on the skin. In the analysis by Abdel-Razek et al. (2023), raw shea butter consisted of around 44 percent stearic acid and around 46 percent oleic acid; its melting point was 32 °C. Fractionation produces a firmer stearin with a melting point of 36 °C and a softer olein with a melting point of 25 °C. According to the same study, shea olein is widely used in cosmetic formulations.

  • Shea butter: firm and easily spreadable, the base of most body butters. Raw material brings its own odor and a batch-dependent color.

  • Shea olein or shea stearin: controls hardness without changing the raw material family. Raw material origin and specification thus remain within a single supply chain.

  • Cocoa butter: significantly harder and more brittle, with a typical inherent odor. It requires controlled crystallization; otherwise, the surface becomes spotted or grainy.

  • Mango or murumuru butter: more neutral scent base for premium lines. Hardness, price, and availability fluctuate more than with shea butter and should be checked with purchasing prior to finalization.

  • Liquid oils and emollients (jojoba, almond, sunflower, squalane): reduce hardness and accelerate absorption. Oils with a high proportion of polyunsaturated fatty acids increase the risk of oxidation.

A benchmark product makes the definition easier. Hardness at room temperature, melting behavior upon application, and residue on the skin can be directly compared to the benchmark using the laboratory sample. How body butter differs from water-rich emulsions is described in the article Having body lotion manufactured.

Refined or unrefined shea butter: what's the difference?

Refined shea butter has less odor and is more oxidatively stable, but loses part of its accompanying substances in the process. Abdel-Razek et al. describe refining as necessary to obtain odorless products with high oxidation stability. At the same time, γ- and δ-tocopherol were completely lost during refining, and in the refined stearin fraction, the total tocopherol content decreased by around 87 percent.

For the formulation, this results in three decisions:

  • Fragrance concept: Unrefined shea butter has an inherent nutty odor that can mask or distort a perfume oil. The fragrance is therefore coordinated with the final butter quality, not with a laboratory standard.

  • Antioxidant: The more unsaturated oils and the fewer natural tocopherols the base contains, the more likely the lipid phase requires an added antioxidant such as tocopherol so that it does not go rancid over its shelf life.

  • Batch variation: Unrefined goods vary in color, odor, and hardness from delivery to delivery. Incoming specifications with limit values for peroxide value, acid value, and color ensure that subsequent production also achieves the same texture.

The choice of quality is therefore also a purchasing decision: refined goods are generally available more consistently, while unrefined goods require tighter incoming goods inspections and, if necessary, a second approved supplier.

Anhydrous, W/O emulsion, or whipped: which formulation type is the right fit?

The formulation type determines preservation and testing scope more strongly than the choice of individual active ingredients. Three basic types are common:

  • Anhydrous body butter: pure lipid phase composed of butters, oils, and optionally waxes. Without a water phase, microorganisms lack the most vital basis for growth; Halla et al. (2018) name water as one of the most critical factors for product contamination. Sensorially rich, absorbs slowly, and leaves a noticeable lipid film.

  • W/O emulsion: water droplets in a continuous lipid phase. Smoother upon application and less greasy, but contains a water phase and therefore typically requires a preservative system, challenge testing according to ISO 11930, and emulsion stability as additional testing points.

  • Whipped body butter: anhydrous base into which air is incorporated during cooling. Lighter in feel, but sensitive to heat: if the structure begins to melt during shipping, the foam collapses and does not reform upon re-solidification.

There is no automatic exemption for anhydrous products. The guidelines for Annex I in Commission Implementing Decision 2013/674/EU distinguish three categories: low microbiological risk products, for which neither a challenge test nor microbiological examination of the finished product is required, but for which scientific justification must be provided; single-use products and packages that cannot be opened; and all other products, which require both tests. Whether an anhydrous body butter in an open jar is considered low-risk is decided by the safety assessor. The jar itself argues against a blanket classification, as water can reach the surface when product is removed with damp fingers.

Why does a body butter become grainy or hard?

Graininess, a hard surface, and oil separation are typical formulation problems with body butter. They are usually due to the crystallization behavior of the fats, not to a single raw material.

Plant butters are mixtures of triglycerides with different melting points. If the mass cools slowly or unevenly, the higher-melting fractions crystallize first and grow into palpable grains. With cocoa butter, this behavior is well studied: It can exist in six crystal forms whose melting points, according to Barišić et al. (2019), range between 17.3 and 36.3 °C, and stable, uniformly sized crystals only form through targeted temperature control. The data come from chocolate manufacturing, but the mechanism affects the same fat in a body butter.

Countermeasures in formulation and process

  • Limit the proportion of high-melting fats using olein fractions or liquid oils if the texture is to be smooth and spreadable.

  • Define the cooling profile: Cooling rate, stirring phase, and temperature of the mass during filling belong in the manufacturing instructions and are documented per batch.

  • Compare laboratory batch and production batch: A one-kilogram laboratory batch cools faster than a production vessel. The crystal structure can therefore change during scale-up and is re-examined on the pilot batch.

Whether the texture holds is only shown by a thermal cycling test. The stability guidelines of Cosmetics Europe and CTFA cite temperature cycles and freeze-thaw tests as methods that make defects such as a tendency to crystallize visible more quickly than storage at a constant temperature. For body butter, this is crucial because the product repeatedly melts slightly and solidifies again in storage, shipping, and the bathroom.

Jar, can or tube: what are the limitations of the packaging?

The jar is the obvious packaging material for solid body butter because the mass can neither be pumped nor reliably squeezed out of a tube. However, it has a hygienic disadvantage: According to Halla et al., jars and bottles are more prone to microbial contamination than closed systems with an airless pump.

  • Glass jar: chemically inert and high-quality in appearance, but heavy, prone to breakage during filling and shipping, and more expensive to transport.

  • Plastic jar made of PP or PET: lightweight and more affordable. However, plastics can leach substances into the product; Murat et al. (2020) identified, among other things, plasticizers and degradation products of antioxidants as potentially leachable substances in cosmetic packaging made of PP and PE; whether they actually migrate into a formulation was not tested by the authors.

  • Aluminum tin: lightweight, lightproof, and shatterproof. Internal coating and skin compatibility with the perfume oil must be tested separately.

  • Tube: only realistic for soft W/O variants, but more hygienic than an open jar.

According to the Guidelines on Annex I, interactions between the product and packaging material, barrier properties, and migration from the packaging material must be taken into account in the safety report. Stability testing is therefore carried out in the final jar, not in laboratory glassware. Temperature also matters during filling: Anhydrous body butter is usually filled hot and liquid and solidifies in the jar. A thin-walled plastic jar must not deform in the process, and the surface should solidify without craters or shrinkage rings.

Two labeling points depend directly on the packaging material. The nominal content is indicated as a weight or volume specification according to Art. 19(1)(b) of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009; in the case of whipped butter, the same jar holds fewer grams due to the lower density, which is why jar size and content declaration are determined based on the final density. Under point (c), if the date of minimum durability is up to 30 months, the best-before date appears on the packaging; for more than 30 months, the period of use after opening is indicated instead. Recyclate and mono-materials are covered in the article Sustainable Cosmetic Packaging.

What testing and documentation are required for market launch?

Prior to placing on the market, the responsible person ensures, in accordance with Article 10 of Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, that a safety assessment has been carried out and a cosmetic product safety report has been drawn up in accordance with Annex I. Pursuant to Article 11, they maintain a product information file, which is kept for ten years after the last batch was placed on the market. For a body butter, these documents are based on the following tests:

  • Stability in the final packaging: texture, odor, color, oxidation, and oil separation at elevated temperature and under alternating temperatures. The guidelines on Annex I require stability to be assessed under reasonably foreseeable storage conditions and to derive the date of minimum durability and period after opening from this.

  • Microbiology: for W/O emulsions, preservation challenge test according to ISO 11930 and microbiological testing of the finished product; for anhydrous formulations, the same tests or a documented, scientifically justified risk assessment.

  • Packaging compatibility: weight loss, discoloration, deformation of the jar, and potential migration from the packaging material.

  • Fragrance allergens: Regulation (EU) 2023/1545 expanded the list of fragrance allergens requiring individual labeling; for leave-on products such as body butter, the labeling threshold of 0.001 percent applies. Products that do not meet the new requirements could only be placed on the market until July 31, 2026, and may be made available until July 31, 2028.

The tests run concurrently with texture adjustment, not subsequent to it. The procedure and duration of the individual tests are described in Stability and Safety Testing for Cosmetics.

How long does development take and what is the minimum order quantity?

How long does development take and what is the minimum order quantity?

How long does development take and what is the minimum order quantity?

Timeline and minimum order quantity depend primarily on the service model and packaging. Labtree operates as a B2B cosmetics developer and cosmetics manufacturer with its own laboratory and production capacities in Germany, covering formulation development, sampling, feasibility testing, and cosmetics production. For a body butter, the following benchmarks apply:

  • White Label: A market-ready, tested Labtree formulation is specifically adapted for the brand; the formulation remains the property of Labtree. With standard packaging, it is typically deliverable within 2 to 3 months.

  • Private Label: New development tailored to the brand's requirements, typically taking 3 to 6 months to market readiness, primarily due to stability testing and regulatory deadlines. Formulation rights or exclusivity are contractually agreed upon.

  • sampling: Samples of pre-qualified formulations are usually dispatched from the sample warehouse within 24 hours; standard sample shipping is free of charge.

  • Minimum order quantity: usually 1,500 units per product, depending on product type, fill size, and packaging.

Reliable unit prices cannot be provided without project details. The primary cost drivers for a body butter are the proportion of specialty butters such as cocoa or murumuru butter, packaging (glass and aluminum versus plastic), perfume oil, and fill size. The most time-critical factors are the availability of raw materials and packaging materials, as well as the completion of stability tests. Where the limits of an adapted standard formulation lie is described in White Label Cosmetics: Advantages and Limits.

Quellen

FAQ

Does an anhydrous body butter need a preservative?

Not necessarily, but any exemption must be justified. The guidelines for Annex I of the Cosmetics Regulation only permit waiving challenge tests and microbiological examinations for products with a low microbiological risk, and this requires scientific justification. In an open jar, water reaches the surface during use, which is why the safety assessor decides on a case-by-case basis. A W/O emulsion contains a water phase and therefore generally requires a preservation system.

Why does body butter become soft or oily in the summer?

Shea butter melts at around 32 °C, shea olein at just about 25 °C, and these temperatures are easily reached in warehouses, parcel delivery, and bathrooms. When it starts to melt, liquid oil separates, and as it resolidifies, grains can form. Higher-melting fractions or waxes stabilize the texture but make it harder; the right compromise is determined through thermal cycle testing in the final jar.

What do the new fragrance allergens mean for a scented body butter?

Regulation (EU) 2023/1545 expands the list of fragrance allergens that must be individually listed in the ingredients list if their concentration exceeds 0.001% in leave-on products. As of August 1, 2026, only products that comply with these requirements may be newly placed on the market; existing stock may continue to be made available until July 31, 2028. To prepare, brands should request updated allergen information from their fragrance oil suppliers and update their labels in good time.

Who owns the formulation of a body butter?

That depends on the service model. With white label, the adapted standard formulation remains with the manufacturer, whereas with private label, formulation rights or exclusivity can be contractually transferred to the brand. The details regarding contract and confidentiality are covered in the magazine article Confidentiality with the contract manufacturer: NDA and formulation ownership.

Can an existing body butter be transferred to a different manufacturer?

Yes, if the complete formulation including raw material grades, raw material specifications, stability data, and the product information file are available. However, the texture must still be retested at the new manufacturer, as the vessel, cooling profile, and filling temperature alter the crystal structure. The process is described in the magazine article "Changing cosmetics manufacturers: How a structured transition works".

What is a realistic minimum order quantity for a body butter?

At Labtree, the minimum order quantity (MOQ) is generally 1,500 units per product, depending on the product type, fill size, and packaging. Custom glass or aluminum jars may involve their own minimum order requirements set by the packaging suppliers. Learn more about what determines minimum order quantities in our magazine article, 'Cosmetics MOQs Explained.'

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get more helpful information about cosmetics development.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get more helpful information about cosmetics development.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get more helpful information about cosmetics development.

Contact us!

>